| 1 | Shane Wynn | WR | 5' 7'' | 157 | So. | Cleveland, Ohio / Glenville | |
| 2 | Cameron Coffman | QB | 6' 2'' | 191 | So. | Peculiar, Mo. / Raymore-Peculiar | Arizona Western C.C. |
| 2 | Dareon Fuller | DB | 5' 7'' | 167 | So. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Arlington | |
| 3 | Cody Latimer | WR | 6' 3'' | 208 | So. | Dayton, Ohio / Jefferson Township | |
| 3 | David Nelson | QB | 5' 11'' | 181 | Fr. | Hudson, Ohio / Hudson | |
| 4 | Corey Babb | QB | 6' 5'' | 221 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 4 | Forisse Hardin | LB | 6' 1'' | 208 | So. | Louisville, Ky. / Ballard | |
|
| 5 | Tre Roberson | QB | 6' 0'' | 190 | So. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Lawrence Central | |
| 6 | Tevin Coleman | RB | 6' 1'' | 200 | Fr. | Tinley Park, Ill. / Oak Forest | |
| 7 | Nate Sudfeld | QB | 6' 5'' | 218 | Fr. | Modesto, Calif. / Modesto Christian | |
| 7 | Brian Williams | CB | 6' 0'' | 185 | R-So. | Lawrenceville, Ga. / Peachtree Ridge | |
| 8 | Kevin Davis | WR | 5' 11'' | 173 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Warren Central | |
| 8 | Drew Hardin | S | 6' 0'' | 208 | R-So. | Louisville, Ky. / Ballard | |
| 9 | Nate Boudreau | QB | 6' 3'' | 209 | Fr. | Naperville, Ill. / Neuqua Valley | |
| 9 | Greg Heban | DB | 6' 1'' | 191 | R-Jr. | Muncie, Ind. / Delta | |
| 10 | Ricky Jones | WR | 5' 10'' | 182 | Fr. | Sarasota, Fla. / Booker | |
| 12 | Mike Caponi | S | 5' 10'' | 172 | R-Fr. | Carol Stream, Ill. / Wheaton North | |
| 12 | Stephen Houston | RB | 6' 0'' | 218 | R-Jr. | Little Rock, Ark. / Lakota West | Independence (Kan. CC |
| 13 | Kofi Hughes | WR | 6' 2'' | 210 | Jr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 14 | Nick Stoner | WR | 6' 1'' | 173 | So. | Greenwood, Ind. / Center Grove | |
| 15 | Damon Graham | RB | 5' 10'' | 178 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Arsenal Tech | |
| 15 | Marcus Kinsella | P | 5' 11'' | 185 | Fr. | Melbourne, Australia / | Ringwood Secondary College |
| 16 | Tyler Brady | QB | 5' 10'' | 195 | Fr. | Prospect Heights, Ill. / Wheeling | |
| 16 | Mitch Ewald | K | 5' 10'' | 173 | R-Jr. | Naperville, Ill. / Waubonsie Valley | |
| 17 | Michael Hunter | CB | 6' 1'' | 183 | So. | Monroe, La. / West Monroe | |
| 17 | Max Matthews | QB | 6' 0'' | 197 | R-Fr. | Granger, Ind. / Saint Joseph | North Central College |
| 18 | Tregg Waters | DB | 6' 0'' | 190 | Jr. | Phoenix, Ariz. / Saint Mary's Catholic | Glendale (Ariz. C.C. |
| 19 | Ryan Parker | WR | 6' 3'' | 183 | So. | Orland Park, Ill. / Carl Sandburg | |
| 19 | Ryan Thompson | S | 5' 10'' | 195 | Jr. | Pontotoc, Miss. / Pontotoc | Itawamba (Miss. C.C. |
| 20 | D'Angelo Roberts | RB | 5' 10'' | 195 | So. | Bloomington, Ind. / Bloomington North | |
| 21 | Jake Zupancic | S | 5' 11'' | 208 | R-So. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 22 | Kenny Mullen | CB | 5' 10'' | 180 | So. | Fort Wayne, Ind. / Bishop Luers | |
|
| 23 | Lawrence Barnett | CB | 5' 10'' | 187 | R-Jr. | Fort Wayne, Ind. / Bishop Luers | |
| 23 | Blair Stellhorn | WR | 5' 9'' | 190 | Fr. | Russiaville, Ind. / Western | |
| 24 | Andre Booker | WR | 5' 11'' | 165 | Fr. | Chesterfield, Mo. / Parkway Central | |
| 24 | David Calhoun | DB | 5' 11'' | 185 | Fr. | Fishers, Ind. / Hamilton Southeastern | |
| 24 | Matt Perez | RB | 5' 11'' | 229 | R-So. | Park Ridge, Ill. / Maine South | |
| 25 | David Blackwell | RB | 6' 1'' | 209 | R-Jr. | Bloomington, Ind. / Bloomington South | |
| 25 | Ryan Phillis | DE | 6' 3'' | 261 | R-So. | Boardman, Ohio / Boardman | |
| 26 | Chandler Miller | WR | 6' 3'' | 197 | Fr. | Richmond, Ind. / Richmond | |
| 26 | Justin Nowak | DB | 6' 0'' | 190 | R-So. | South Bend, Ind. / Washington | |
| 27 | Alexander Webb | S | 6' 0'' | 200 | R-Sr. | Mequon, Wis. / Homestead | |
| 28 | Anthony Davis | RB | 5' 8'' | 196 | So. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Warren Central | University of Dayton |
| 28 | Antonio Marshall | CB | 5' 11'' | 188 | R-Jr. | Pitts, Ga. / Wilcox County | Georgia Military College |
| 29 | Dawson Fletcher | S | 6' 0'' | 196 | Fr. | West Chester, Ohio / Lakota West | |
| 29 | Jordan Jackson | TE | 6' 3'' | 219 | R-Fr. | Trafalgar, Ind. / Indian Creek | |
| 30 | Tyler Burgett | LB | 6' 0'' | 212 | Fr. | Sarasota, Fla. / Out-of-Door Academy | |
| 30 | Nathan Reisman | P | 6' 0'' | 194 | R-Jr. | Dallas, Texas / Pearce | |
| 31 | Tyler Reeves | S | 6' 0'' | 204 | R-So. | Carmel, Ind. / Noblesville | |
| 31 | Jordan Wallace | LB | 6' 0'' | 229 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Warren Central | |
| 33 | Christian Englum | TE | 6' 6'' | 205 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Park Tudor | |
| 33 | Zack Shaw | DE | 6' 3'' | 245 | R-Fr. | Coshocton, Ohio / Coshocton | |
| 34 | Jacarri Alexander | LB | 6' 1'' | 232 | R-Jr. | Winter Haven, Fla. / Auburndale | Iowa Central C.C. |
| 35 | Quai Chandler | DB | 6' 0'' | 180 | Fr. | Lake Forest, Ill. / Lake Forest Academy | |
| 35 | Mitchell Voss | K/P | 5' 11'' | 177 | R-Jr. | Valparaiso, Ind. / Wheeler | Ferris State University |
| 36 | Tim Bennett | DB | 5' 9'' | 181 | So. | Columbus, Ga. / Northside | Ellsworth (Iowa C.C. |
| 37 | Mark Murphy | S | 6' 2'' | 206 | So. | Akron, Ohio / St. Vincent-St. Mary | |
|
| 38 | Isaiah Roundtree | RB | 5' 11'' | 190 | R-So. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Lawrence Central | Morehead State University |
| 38 | Garrett Welch | DB | 6' 1'' | 192 | Fr. | Zionsville, Ind. / Noblesville | |
| 39 | Erich Toth | K/P | 6' 3'' | 190 | R-Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Brebeuf Jesuit | |
| 40 | Chase Parker | LB | 6' 0'' | 195 | R-Fr. | South Bend, Ind. / Marian | Seton Hill University |
| 40 | Matt Zakrzewski | FB | 6' 2'' | 240 | R-So. | Traverse City, Mich. / St. Francis | |
| 41 | Tanner Kearns | TE | 6' 5'' | 218 | Fr. | Lexington, Ohio / Lexington | |
| 42 | David Cooper | LB | 6' 1'' | 225 | R-So. | Lilburn, Ga. / Brookwood | Coffeyville (Kan.) C.C. |
| 42 | Chad Roggeman | P | 6' 0'' | 178 | R-Jr. | Mishawaka, Ind. / Mishawaka | |
| 43 | Brandon Grubbe | LB | 5' 11'' | 200 | R-So. | Lowell, Ind. / Lowell | Butler University |
| 43 | Ishmael Thomas | LB | 6' 5'' | 218 | R-So. | Detroit, Mich. / Renaissance | |
| 44 | Adam Kranda | DE | 6' 6'' | 261 | Fr. | New Castle, Ind. / New Castle | |
| 44 | Andrew Wilson | RB | 5' 11'' | 207 | Fr. | Columbus, Ind. / Columbus East | |
| 45 | Dimitrius Carr-Watson | FB | 6' 1'' | 240 | R-Jr. | Calumet City, Ill. / Mount Carmel | |
| 46 | Mike Replogle | DE | 6' 2'' | 235 | So. | Centerville, Ohio / Centerville | |
| 47 | Chase Hoobler | LB | 6' 2'' | 242 | R-So. | Orrville, Ohio / Orrville | |
| 48 | Simeon Ikudabo | LB | 6' 3'' | 225 | R-Fr. | Marion, Ind. / Marion | University of Akron |
| 49 | Griffen Dahlstrom | LB | 6' 3'' | 226 | R-Jr. | Coatesville, Ind. / North Putnam | |
| 50 | Jake Reed | OL | 6' 4'' | 275 | So. | Columbus, Ind. / Columbus North | |
| 51 | Kyle Kennedy | LB | 6' 3'' | 232 | R-Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 52 | Austin Schlosser | LB | 5' 11'' | 201 | Fr. | Naperville, Ill. / Neuqua Valley | |
| 53 | Shawn Heffern | DE | 6' 6'' | 244 | Fr. | Carmel, Ind. / Carmel | |
| 54 | Alex Ziedas | OL | 6' 2'' | 283 | Fr. | Detroit, Mich. / | University of Detroit Jesuit |
| 55 | Jake Michalek | LB | 6' 2'' | 242 | R-So. | Midlothian, Ill. / Brother Rice | |
| 56 | Nick Mangieri | DE | 6' 5'' | 242 | Fr. | Peoria, Ill. / Dunlap | |
| 57 | Pete Bachman | OT | 6' 5'' | 285 | R-So. | Cincinnati, Ohio / Elder | |
|
| 58 | Tyler McGuigan | DT | 6' 2'' | 286 | R-Jr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Lawrence North | |
| 59 | Peyton Eckert | OT | 6' 6'' | 293 | So. | Arlington Heights, Ill. / Prospect | |
| 60 | Will Matte | C | 6' 2'' | 292 | R-Sr. | Wheaton, Ill. / Wheaton-Warrenville South | |
| 61 | Bryce Werskey | LB | 6' 1'' | 225 | Fr. | Seymour, Ind. / Seymour | |
| 62 | Ralston Evans | OL | 6' 4'' | 284 | R-Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Arlington | |
| 63 | Jerrell Kirlew | DT | 6' 3'' | 266 | R-Sr. | Kissimmee, Fla. / Poinciana | |
| 63 | Tyler Lukens | OL | 6' 0'' | 270 | R-Fr. | South Bend, Ind. / Saint Joseph | Sienna Heights University |
| 64 | Collin Rahrig | OL | 6' 2'' | 278 | R-So. | South Bend, Ind. / Marian | |
| 65 | Wes Rogers | OL | 6' 4'' | 280 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Lawrence Central | |
| 67 | Dan Feeney | OL | 6' 4'' | 293 | Fr. | Orland Park, Ill. / Carl Sandburg | |
| 68 | David Kaminski | OL | 6' 4'' | 284 | R-Fr. | Strongsville, Ohio / Strongsville | |
| 69 | Alex Todd | DT | 6' 3'' | 277 | Fr. | Streetsboro, Ohio / Streetsboro | |
| 70 | Jacob Bailey | OL | 6' 5'' | 285 | Fr. | Carmel, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 71 | Bill Ivan | OT | 6' 4'' | 295 | R-So. | Charlevoix, Mich. / Charlevoix | |
| 72 | Michael Mitsch | DT | 5' 11'' | 264 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 73 | Bernard Taylor | OL | 6' 2'' | 292 | So. | Detroit, Mich. / Dakota | |
| 74 | Charlie Chapman | OT | 6' 6'' | 300 | R-Jr. | South Rockwood, Mich. / Airport | |
| 75 | Nicholas Sliger | DT | 6' 3'' | 290 | R-Sr. | Cicero, Ind. / Hamilton Southeastern | |
| 76 | Cody Evers | OL | 6' 4'' | 304 | R-So. | Little Chute, Wis. / Little Chute | |
| 77 | Dimitric Camiel | OT | 6' 7'' | 295 | Fr. | Houston, Texas / Westfield | |
| 78 | Jason Spriggs | OT | 6' 7'' | 268 | Fr. | Elkhart, Ind. / Concord | |
| 79 | Gregory Lewis | OL | 6' 5'' | 295 | R-Fr. | Fort Lauderdale, Fla. / Chaminade-Madonna | |
| 80 | Sean Damaska | WR | 6' 7'' | 215 | Fr. | Milton, Ga. / Blessed Trinity Catholic | |
| 81 | Duwyce Wilson | WR | 6' 3'' | 195 | R-Jr. | Columbus, Ind. / Columbus East | |
| 82 | Sean Barrett | LS | 6' 6'' | 200 | Fr. | Carmel, Ind. / Carmel | |
|
| 82 | Caleb Cornett | WR | 6' 3'' | 183 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Ben Davis | |
| 83 | Ted Bolser | TE | 6' 6'' | 250 | R-Jr. | Cincinnati, Ohio / Indian Hill | |
| 84 | Jamonne Chester | WR | 6' 2'' | 210 | R-Jr. | Detroit, Mich. / Redford Covenant | |
| 85 | Charles Love III | TE | 6' 3'' | 240 | R-Sr. | Memphis, Tenn. / Trezevant | |
| 86 | Paul Phillips | TE | 6' 5'' | 251 | R-So. | Darnestown, Md. / Georgetown Prep | |
| 87 | Leneil Himes | DT | 6' 1'' | 277 | R-So. | Plymouth, Ind. / Plymouth | |
| 87 | Mitchell Paige | WR | 5' 7'' | 166 | Fr. | Carmel, Ind. / Guerin Catholic | |
| 88 | Anthony Corsaro | TE | 6' 1'' | 242 | Fr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral | |
| 89 | Mike Carter | FB | 6' 1'' | 220 | R-Jr. | Jeffersonville, Ind. / Jeffersonville | |
| 90 | Garrett Libertowski | DE | 5' 11'' | 206 | R-Fr. | Granger, Ind. / Saint Joseph | Charleston Southern University |
| 91 | Matt Dooley | LS | 6' 4'' | 257 | So. | Phoenix, Ariz. / Scottsdale Christian Academy | |
| 92 | Justin Rayside | DE | 6' 3'' | 250 | Jr. | Corona, Calif. / Eleanor Roosevelt | Riverside (Calif. C.C. |
| 93 | Nick Campos | P | 6' 0'' | 182 | Fr. | Wheaton, Ill. / Wheaton-Warrenville South | |
| 93 | Ralphael Green | DT | 6' 5'' | 318 | Fr. | San Antonio, Texas / Sam Houston | |
| 94 | Javon Cornley | DE | 6' 5'' | 251 | R-Jr. | Columbus, Ohio / Northland | |
| 95 | Bobby Richardson | DE | 6' 3'' | 279 | So. | Tampa, Fla. / Plant | |
| 96 | John Laihinen | DE | 6' 4'' | 250 | R-So. | Mequon, Wis. / Homestead | |
| 97 | Larry Black Jr. | DT | 6' 2'' | 294 | R-Sr. | Cincinnati, Ohio / Wyoming | |
| 98 | Adam Replogle | DT | 6' 3'' | 294 | Sr. | Centerville, Ohio / Centerville | |
| 99 | Nick Freeland | K/P | 6' 0'' | 201 | R-Sr. | Indianapolis, Ind. / Lawrence North | |
| 99 | Adarius Rayner | DT | 6' 2'' | 292 | R-Fr. | Largo, Fla. / Largo | |